November 19, 2026

What Is a Troubled Heart?

The Untroubled Heart · Part 3 of 5
John 16:33 (ESV)

“In the world you will have tribulation. But take heart; I have overcome the world.”

In the Bible, the heart is the command center of a whole life — deeper than thought or feeling. Jesus told His disciples not to let that command center be “troubled.” What exactly did He mean?

Stirred Up

The word Jesus uses for troubled (tarasso) means to disturb, to agitate, to stir up, to unsettle.

The invalid at Bethesda speaks of the water being “stirred up” (John 5:7). Paul speaks of teachers who stir up trouble at the churches (see Galatians 1:7, 5:10). And, interestingly, the same word is used several times to describe Jesus’ soul (John 11:33 at Lazarus’ tomb and John 12:27 as He considers the move toward the cross). Judas’ betrayal “troubled” Jesus “in his spirit” (John 13:21).

A troubled heart is a heart that is “stirred up” and “disturbed.”

The person with a troubled heart is, to use Dudley Hall’s words, “not sitting down on the inside.”

The untroubled heart is not the absence of emotional pain. It is quite possible to be emotionally sad, even intensely grieving, and have an untroubled heart. Oh, how many saints I’ve witnessed in that precious place, saying, “I am glad he’s in heaven and I’m at peace, but I’m so very sad because I miss him so.”

Fear and Anxiety

The troubled heart is not the brain’s amygdala response that I experienced last summer while on a hike in Montreat, North Carolina when I paused at a vista and suddenly noticed I was standing two feet from a huge timber rattlesnake, coiled beneath me. That God-given jolt of alert put me into freeze then flight (definitely not fight). As soon as I was safely away from the snake, the fear quickly abated.

But imagine the rest of my hike on Lookout Mountain! Every stick looked like a snake. I quit enjoying the vistas and started staring at the ground. For the rest of the hike, I lost my carefree heart.

The diagnostic manual of psychiatry (DSM-5-TR) defines fear and anxiety this way:

Fear is the emotional response to real or perceived imminent threat, whereas anxiety is anticipation of future threat.1

DSM-5-TR • American Psychiatric Association

The troubled heart has received a signal that something is wrong. Something is threatening or out of place or dangerous. When the heart believes that anxious signal as truth, it predicts that version of truth for future life.

Bessel van der Kolk, author of the seminal The Body Keeps the Score, describes trauma as an event that overwhelms the central nervous system, altering the way memories are processed and recalled.2

Imagine if, instead of merely seeing the rattler at my feet, I had stepped on it and been poisoned. Though the hypothetical snakebite would have been the only snakebite I’d ever experienced, and though being bitten ever again would be highly unlikely, it would be challenging to ever deeply enjoy a hike on that mountain again.

Further, imagine if I had been hiking alone and was bitten. The isolation would severely heighten the trauma.

Van der Kolk argues that the presence or absence of safe human connection is one of the major factors determining whether an overwhelming experience becomes an enduring trauma.3

The event itself matters profoundly, but research also shows that perceived helplessness, isolation, and the absence of safe human connection can intensify its traumatic impact.

“I Will Be with You”

Jesus’ promise of His ongoing presence with the disciples is more than reassurance; it is preemptive and protective. Instead of declaring “peace, peace” where there is no peace, Jesus starkly predicts the trouble the disciples will face (John 16:33) and promises that He’ll be with them:

“And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come again and will take you to myself, that where I am you may be also.” John 14:3

“And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Helper, to be with you forever.” John 14:16

“If anyone loves me, he will keep my word, and my Father will love him, and we will come to him and make our home with him.” John 14:23

“You heard me say to you, ‘I am going away, and I will come to you.’ If you loved me, you would have rejoiced, because I am going to the Father, for the Father is greater than I.” John 14:28

“I am the vine; you are the branches. Whoever abides in me and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit, for apart from me you can do nothing.” John 15:5

“He will glorify me, for he will take what is mine and declare it to you.” John 16:14

John 16:33

“Take heart;
I have overcome the world.”

Held

Our two-month-old grandson, Ezekiel, recently required a significant surgery to correct a prematurely fused skull. The endoscopic craniectomy removes a strip of skull to allow the brain to grow and develop normally. We prayed for the pediatric neurosurgeon and the medical team. We prayed for the success of the surgery and the protection of the life of the baby. But I found myself praying just as fervently for the protection of his infant soul — that this frightening experience would not be encoded as lasting trauma.

When, pre-surgery, Ezekiel needed to receive a CT scan, the technicians hoped that the baby might just be asleep when taken into the big, open machine. But, instead, our son Bennett was feeding the baby a bottle, the child lying on his back on the mobile table, the father crouched over him, holding the bottle and smiling and speaking lovingly. So, the technician encouraged Bennett to just ride into the scan with the baby. So, he did. And Ezekiel was still. While the big machine did its work, instead of fearing the unknown, the baby took nourishment and gazed at the smile of his father.

After the successful surgery, the parents were allowed to stay in the PICU with Ezekiel. Because of the large, painful incision on the back of his head, the baby couldn’t lie down. So, the parents held him for most of the first two days. Held as he slept. Held as he cried. Held as he ate.

I later mused with Bennett, “Whatever strain the experience placed on his little body, he was surrounded throughout it by a more powerful message: You are held. You are loved. You are not alone.”

I think Jesus offers something like this in His final discourse. He says “You’ll go through some difficult and scary things, but you won’t be going through it alone. I’ll be with you. You’ll be with me. Therefore, you’ll be OK. I do not promise that your souls will not face sorrow; they will. I do not promise that your bodies will not face discomfort or even death; it is possible. But your heart need not be troubled.”

The troubled heart is an inner command center that has received messages of fear and trauma and internalized the messages as truth. But Jesus’ presence and Jesus’ truth are the cure.

According to psychologists, anxiety is rooted in both the perception of a difficult or negative future happening AND in the perceived inability to handle it.

What Jesus offers the disciples (and us) is a realignment of heart that will enable them to rightly assess both the danger and the capacity to make it through.

Jesus does not merely offer a technique or a process. He offers Himself — and He offers His peace. He offers His own untroubled heart. He offers a share of His own peace.

Whatever trouble you are facing today, I bless you to know that you are not facing it alone. You are held. You are loved. And the One who holds you has overcome the world.

Next in the series: My Peace I Give You. New to the series? Start with Part 1: His Final Words.

Notes

1. American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th ed., text rev. (APA Publishing, 2022), 215.

2. Bessel van der Kolk, “When Is It Trauma? Bessel van der Kolk Explains,” interview by Rich Simon, Psychotherapy Networker.

3. Bessel van der Kolk, The Body Keeps the Score (Viking, 2014), 81, 212.

en_USEnglish